Whalers in Norway continue to carry out commercial whaling despite falling demand for whale meat and a decline in the number of boats hunting each year.
Norway hunts minke whales under an 'objection' to the International Whaling Commission's (IWC) global ban on commercial whaling, which came into effect in 1986. Initially, the hunts were undertaken under the guise of ‘science’ but in 1993, Norway resumed full-blown commercial whaling, citing this ‘objection’.
Minke whaling in Norway is conducted by fishermen, the vast majority of whom resume fishing activities outside the whaling season. The hunts rely on state subsidies and the government is constantly searching for new markets to exploit, with young people and tourists their main targets.
Whaling in Norway - facts
- Norway kills hundreds of minke whales each year
- Many of the whales targeted are pregnant females
- Norway hunts whales under an 'objection' to the global ban on commercial whaling
- The hunts are heavily subsidised by the government, which constantly seeks to develop new markets
- The government promotes whale meat to schoolchildren and young people are offered whale burgers at festivals
- Tourists are offered whale meat in restaurants and aboard cruise ships
Whaling in Norway - figures
Norway kills minke whales under a self-allocated quota, currently 1,278 for the 2019 season which began on 1st April. This quota, the same as for 2018 (previous quotas were 999 in 2017 and 880 in 2016) seems largely symbolic, since the number of whales killed over the years has usually fallen far short of the official quota.
2017 saw 432 minkes killed: the lowest catch since 1996 and also the lowest number of vessels actively whaling for 25 years. 434 whales were killed in 2018, again well short of the quota, thus begging the question: why set such a high quota when, mercifully, it is never fulfilled? The answer lies partly in the Norwegian government’s defensive stance towards whaling and its ambition to increase domestic demand for whale meat, and even export whale meat to Japan.
Who eats minke whale meat?
Young Norwegians are targeted, but most consumers are elderly
Despite massive government subsidies and marketing campaigns over the past 25 years, domestic demand for whale meat is declining within Norway and fewer than 5% of Norwegians - mostly older people - regularly eat the meat. This decline has forced the industry to be more creative in its attempts to spark an interest in whale meat in other sectors of the population. However, efforts in recent years to promote products such as whale burgers and whale sushi to students and young people attending popular Norwegian music festivals such as Bukta, Træna or Inferno, have largely flopped.
Undaunted, last summer, Norwegian fisheries minister, Per Sandberg pledged grants of almost 1.2 million kroner (over £100,000) to food festivals and other initiatives to promote whale meat as a new and exciting food for schoolchildren and young people to experience. At the time, he exclaimed that “whales are a healthy alternative to red meat and whale meat is good for the health!”
In early 2017, we reported on efforts to offload around 60 tons of Norwegian minke whale meat to ‘needy people’. However, this apparent act of philanthropy was swiftly revealed as a PR stunt, as the meat - donated by Myklebust Hvalprodukter, based in western Norway and one of the country’s largest whale meat processors and exporters - was nearing its sell-by date!
Clearly panicked by local disinterest, the Norwegian government’s response is to go on the attack. In January 2018, Mr Sandberg declared that he wants to boost demand for whale meat, exclaiming "I want to make sure that whaling stays alive!" Whilst acknowledging that public demand for whale meat is falling, Sandberg said that he will support a marketing programme aimed at encouraging Norwegians – especially children and young people - to eat more whale meat as it is a ‘tasty and healthy food’.
Unwary tourists keep the trade alive
“Wandering around Tromsø, it’s easy to be struck by the number of venues boasting whale for sale. As if killing whales – when most of the rest of the world respects the international ban – was not enough, it felt doubly insulting to see Norwegian minke whale carpaccio feature on one harbourside menu at 115 NOK (around £11), the same price as onion rings and chips - and cheaper than a green salad! Can the life of a beautiful, sentient creature really be valued so cheaply? [Journal entry, Vanessa Williams-Grey, Tromso July 2017]
Tourists are a prime target for those marketing whale meat, which is sold in supermarkets, dockside fish markets, restaurants and aboard cruise ships. Skincare products and supplements containing whale, such as ‘whale oil’ capsules and skin creams, are also widely available.
It could be that many tourists have yet to realise that, by purchasing whale products, they are helping to perpetuate an industry that could otherwise have died by now. Following the success of our outreach campaign to tourists visiting Iceland, which dramatically reduced demand for whale meat , we’re reaching out to tourists to Norway with a similar message: please don’t eat whale! We hope tourists will lose their appetite for whale meat once they realise the steak on their plate may well have come from a terrified pregnant whale.
Prior to the ban on commercial whaling, Norway exported over 50% of its whale products to Japan. After the moratorium, Norway originally agreed to halt trade in whale products, but resumed exports in 2001.
Isn’t it illegal to ship whale meat halfway across the globe?
Sadly no. As is the case with Icelandic whale meat exports, the shocking truth is that Norway, along with Japan and Iceland, holds a ‘reservation’ against the listing of minke whales under Appendix 1 of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) and, therefore, can legally trade whale products with each other.
Exported meat not fit to eat?
Most shipments go to Japan, although Norway also ships whale meat to Iceland and the Faroe Islands, for example:
February 2013: 4,250 kilos of frozen whale belly meat, blubber, tails and fins were exported to Japan. The shipment sailed aboard the ECL Commander to Rotterdam where the meat transferred to the NYK Olympus before sailing on in early March, transiting Le Havre, Hamburg and Southampton, before heading on to Japan via the Suez Canal.
March 2015: Japan dumped a shipment of Norwegian minke whale meat after routine safety tests discovered that it contained up to twice the permitted level of aldrin, dieldrin and chlordane. These pesticides are banned in some countries and suspected of causing birth defects, neurological harm and some cancers if consumed in high quantities.
October 2016: 3,455 kilos of whale meat were shipped to Japan via Hamburg.
July 2017: 432 kilos of whale meat was exported to the Faroe Islands.
EU Resolution calls for an end to the movement of whale meat through its ports
The EU currently allows ships carrying whale meat and products to dock at their ports, despite the UK and many EU countries being opposed to whale hunting. Icelandic and Norwegian whalers have shipped and transferred whale products through ports such as Southampton, Rotterdam and Hamburg in the past. Over 100,000 people recently joined the WDC campaign to bring an end to this practice, which was further boosted by a resounding show of support from European MEPs, an overwhelming majority of whom voted in favour of a resolution to end the shipment of whale meat through EU ports.
The Resolution gives a clear mandate to the EU Commission to do its utmost to end the EU's indirect support of Norway's whaling activities, calling on the Commission to ‘look into all possible ways of ensuring that whale meat is no longer legally allowed to transit through EU ports, including by recommending a ban on such transits as an exceptional measure.’ The resolution also calls on Norway to cease all its commercial whaling operations and to abide by the current international ban on commercial whaling and the international ban on trade in whale meat and products.
WDC says: We worked very hard, alongside NGO colleagues, to secure the support of MEPs on this issue. We are delighted with the outcome as it sends a strong signal to the EU Commission and all Member States that killing whales is cruel, unnecessary and not at all in line with EU policies. We will fight on to turn this political support into a legal ban.
WDC working to end whaling in Norway
Whalers much prefer to keep the public, including their own population, in the dark, feeding them misinformation. The very last thing they want is for anyone to shine a spotlight on their activities, so one of the most important things WDC can do is to publicise the cruelty of their hunts and highlight what people can do to help.
For example, we have:
- Mustered over 100,000 signatures to a petition supporting a Resolution by European MEPs to the EU Commission calling for a ban on the transit of whalemeat from Norway (and other whaling regions) through our ports.
- Produced flyers informing tourists to Norway exactly why they should avoid supporting the killing by eating whale meat or purchasing products made from whales.
- Publicised the large percentage of pregnant females killed in the hunts. This is by no means the ‘accident’ the whalers claim but rather, a cynical exploitation of the fact that pregnant whales are easy targets, being larger and slower.
- Briefed the media repeatedly on the cruelty and wastage involved in the hunts including dumping whale carcasses overboard in view of passenger boats or close to harbours.
- Worked with whale watch tourism experts within Norway to approach the government, calling for regulations to improve the current industry, as a responsible, profitable whale watch industry is one of the most powerful arguments against whaling: every whale killed is one fewer to be watched.
Help protect whales and dolphins from the threats they face
By adopting a dolphin or by making a donation, you can help us save these amazing creatures.
Adopt a dolphin and follow the lives of these amazing creatures.
Your gifts help us take action to protect their homes.